Error convert HEIC to PNG.

[Ryanb58]

iPhone 15 Pro upload to GDrive...
Downloaded on laptop as HEIC.
Attempted to convert to PNG using VIPS & graphicsmagick.

Both failed.

Logs below. The image opens as expected on my mac.

2024-12-27T21:40:49.027136550Z ConvertX v0.9.0
2024-12-27T21:40:49.072718713Z 🦊 Elysia is running at http://localhost:3000
2024-12-27T21:40:49.088217429Z Alpine Linux v3.20
2024-12-27T21:40:49.088443415Z GraphicsMagick 1.3.43 2024-03-23 Q16 http://www.GraphicsMagick.org/
2024-12-27T21:40:49.088516201Z resvg v0.44.0
2024-12-27T21:40:49.088611241Z pandoc 3.1.13
2024-12-27T21:40:49.088702642Z assimp vVersion 5.4 -shared -st (GIT commit 0)
2024-12-27T21:40:49.088806158Z XeTeX 3.141592653-2.6-0.999996 (TeX Live 2024/Alpine Linux)
2024-12-27T21:40:49.088911016Z Bun v1.1.36
2024-12-27T21:40:49.089046801Z djxl v0.10.2 [AVX2,SSE4,SSE2]
2024-12-27T21:40:49.089139095Z vips-8.15.2
2024-12-27T21:40:49.089830157Z ffmpeg version 6.1.1 Copyright (c) 2000-2023 the FFmpeg developers
2024-12-27T21:40:49.142948211Z Inkscape 1.3.2 (091e20ef0f, 2023-11-25)
2024-12-27T21:45:12.617841350Z jobId set to: 18
2024-12-27T21:45:37.331261346Z stderr: ./data/uploads/1/18/IMG_5021.HEIC: bad seek to 1955775
2024-12-27T21:45:37.331312834Z heif: Invalid input: Unspecified: Metadata not correctly assigned to image (2.0)
2024-12-27T21:45:37.331320549Z 
2024-12-27T21:45:37.331331629Z Failed to convert ./data/uploads/1/18/IMG_5021.HEIC from heic to png using vips. error: Error: Command failed: vips copy "./data/uploads/1/18/IMG_5021.HEIC" "./data/output/1/18/IMG_5021.png"
2024-12-27T21:45:37.331343392Z ./data/uploads/1/18/IMG_5021.HEIC: bad seek to 1955775
2024-12-27T21:45:37.331348862Z heif: Invalid input: Unspecified: Metadata not correctly assigned to image (2.0)
2024-12-27T21:45:37.331353991Z 
2024-12-27T21:45:39.765585824Z 2 | (function (process, nextTickQueue, drainMicrotasksFn, reportUncaughtExceptionFn) {"use strict";
2024-12-27T21:45:39.765618105Z 3 |   var queue, process, nextTickQueue = nextTickQueue, drainMicrotasks = drainMicrotasksFn, reportUncaughtException = reportUncaughtExceptionFn;
2024-12-27T21:45:39.765622775Z 4 |   let { validateFunction } = @getInternalField(@internalModuleRegistry, 21) || @createInternalModuleById(21);
2024-12-27T21:45:39.765626712Z 5 |   var setup = () => {
2024-12-27T21:45:39.765630679Z 6 |     let { FixedQueue } = @getInternalField(@internalModuleRegistry, 11) || @createInternalModuleById(11);
2024-12-27T21:45:39.765634166Z - |     function processTicksAndRejections() {
2024-12-27T21:45:39.765637532Z ENOENT: No such file or directory
2024-12-27T21:45:39.765640778Z    errno: -2
2024-12-27T21:45:39.765644064Z  syscall: "open"
2024-12-27T21:45:39.765647421Z    path: "./data/output/1/18/IMG_5021.png"
2024-12-27T21:45:39.765650797Z 
2024-12-27T21:45:46.131953998Z 2 | (function (process, nextTickQueue, drainMicrotasksFn, reportUncaughtExceptionFn) {"use strict";
2024-12-27T21:45:46.131987991Z 3 |   var queue, process, nextTickQueue = nextTickQueue, drainMicrotasks = drainMicrotasksFn, reportUncaughtException = reportUncaughtExceptionFn;
2024-12-27T21:45:46.132008291Z 4 |   let { validateFunction } = @getInternalField(@internalModuleRegistry, 21) || @createInternalModuleById(21);
2024-12-27T21:45:46.132011827Z 5 |   var setup = () => {
2024-12-27T21:45:46.132015134Z 6 |     let { FixedQueue } = @getInternalField(@internalModuleRegistry, 11) || @createInternalModuleById(11);
2024-12-27T21:45:46.132017949Z - |     function processTicksAndRejections() {
2024-12-27T21:45:46.132020573Z ENOENT: No such file or directory
2024-12-27T21:45:46.132023449Z    errno: -2
2024-12-27T21:45:46.132025954Z  syscall: "open"
2024-12-27T21:45:46.132028639Z    path: "./data/output/1/18/IMG_5021.png"
2024-12-27T21:45:46.132031294Z 
2024-12-27T21:45:50.802921438Z jobId set to: 19
2024-12-27T21:46:00.304278206Z stderr: gm convert: An error has occurred reading from file (./data/uploads/1/19/IMG_5021.HEIC).
2024-12-27T21:46:00.304308723Z 
2024-12-27T21:46:00.304314435Z Failed to convert ./data/uploads/1/19/IMG_5021.HEIC from heic to png using graphicsmagick. error: Error: Command failed: gm convert "./data/uploads/1/19/IMG_5021.HEIC" "./data/output/1/19/IMG_5021.png"
2024-12-27T21:46:00.304321147Z gm convert: An error has occurred reading from file (./data/uploads/1/19/IMG_5021.HEIC).
2024-12-27T21:46:00.304325946Z 
2024-12-27T21:46:08.832843103Z 2 | (function (process, nextTickQueue, drainMicrotasksFn, reportUncaughtExceptionFn) {"use strict";
2024-12-27T21:46:08.832880074Z 3 |   var queue, process, nextTickQueue = nextTickQueue, drainMicrotasks = drainMicrotasksFn, reportUncaughtException = reportUncaughtExceptionFn;
2024-12-27T21:46:08.832885784Z 4 |   let { validateFunction } = @getInternalField(@internalModuleRegistry, 21) || @createInternalModuleById(21);
2024-12-27T21:46:08.832916803Z 5 |   var setup = () => {
2024-12-27T21:46:08.832921612Z 6 |     let { FixedQueue } = @getInternalField(@internalModuleRegistry, 11) || @createInternalModuleById(11);
2024-12-27T21:46:08.832926050Z - |     function processTicksAndRejections() {
2024-12-27T21:46:08.832930168Z ENOENT: No such file or directory
2024-12-27T21:46:08.832934556Z    errno: -2
2024-12-27T21:46:08.832938994Z  syscall: "open"
2024-12-27T21:46:08.832943202Z    path: "./data/output/1/18/IMG_5021.png"
2024-12-27T21:46:08.832947431Z 
2024-12-27T21:46:11.581633780Z 2 | (function (process, nextTickQueue, drainMicrotasksFn, reportUncaughtExceptionFn) {"use strict";
2024-12-27T21:46:11.581666542Z 3 |   var queue, process, nextTickQueue = nextTickQueue, drainMicrotasks = drainMicrotasksFn, reportUncaughtException = reportUncaughtExceptionFn;
2024-12-27T21:46:11.581671121Z 4 |   let { validateFunction } = @getInternalField(@internalModuleRegistry, 21) || @createInternalModuleById(21);
2024-12-27T21:46:11.581674817Z 5 |   var setup = () => {
2024-12-27T21:46:11.581693593Z 6 |     let { FixedQueue } = @getInternalField(@internalModuleRegistry, 11) || @createInternalModuleById(11);
2024-12-27T21:46:11.581696087Z - |     function processTicksAndRejections() {
2024-12-27T21:46:11.581698151Z ENOENT: No such file or directory
2024-12-27T21:46:11.581700185Z    errno: -2
2024-12-27T21:46:11.581702189Z  syscall: "open"
2024-12-27T21:46:11.581704403Z    path: "./data/output/1/18/IMG_5021.png"
2024-12-27T21:46:11.581706877Z 
2024-12-27T21:46:29.084273574Z jobId set to: 20

[C4illin]

Similar to #185 and #168

[C4illin]

ENOENT: No such file or directory means the file didn't upload correctly. The first error seem to hint that the image is corrupt or is using some new heic feature

[1C26EF6D73]

I have the same problem. I figured out that the orientation of the picture isn't in the recommended format.
E.g. "pic_001.heic" has the resolution 4096 x 6144 px. Because I took the picture in portrait format and not in landscape format.

Could you confirm that?
If yes, is it possible to fix it?

[C4illin]

Maybe both Vips and Graphics magick lack support for that heic feature? Maybe test locally with the latest version

[brandonnly]

Also getting the same error, it looks like its a recent iOS 18 HEIC issue: libvips/libvips#4169

Looks like its been patched in libvips versions >= 8.15.4, but the alpine packages still use 8.15.3-r5: https://pkgs.alpinelinux.org/package/edge/community/x86_64/vips

[C4illin]

Ohh great find! Then there isn't much to do except wait

[C4illin]

Seems like the vips package is lacking a maintainer https://gitlab.alpinelinux.org/alpine/aports/-/merge_requests/75861

[mattlathrop]

From the second answer here it seems like libheif has an utility to convert the images that works with recent iOS. Perhaps we could integrate that? Though not sure you want another dependency.

[C4illin]

I added libheif, just for decode using the heif-convert tool. Could you test in iOS 18?